Event 080 β Jesus Heals a Demon-Possessed Man
Era: V β Galilean Ministry II (era name as given in the vault stub)
Gospel Reference: Matthew 9:32β34
Location: Galilee (sheet) β Matthew names no place: the scene follows the blind men's departure ("when they were gone out," 9:32) in the same unnamed house-and-road world as Events 078β079. The sheet's region is all that either text or list assigns, and the page narrows it no further.
AVAKOD date: Summer 32 AD (master list, AD 33 framework). Three verses β the shortest complete scene of the batch, and the one that ends Matthew's chapter 9 cycle with a sentence of wonder answered by a sentence of accusation.
My Study β Event 080
Sign in to mark this event as read and keep your own notes. Sign in
Bible Text β Douay-Rheims, Challoner Revision
Matthew 9:32β34
32 And when they were gone out, behold they brought him a dumb man, possessed with a devil.
33 And after the devil was cast out, the dumb man spoke, and the multitudes wondered, saying, Never was the like seen in Israel.
34 But the Pharisees said, By the prince of devils he casteth out devils.
Note on names and words: the DRC's "dumb" is the period's word for speechless β the man's affliction is that he cannot speak, and the cure is registered in exactly that coin: "the dumb man spoke." The Greek word can cover deafness as well; the passage itself resolves it by its outcome, and the page keeps the DRC's word. The man is brought by others β "they brought him" β and speaks no word before his cure and records none after it: his whole part in his own story is the speaking itself. Verse 34's charge stands in the Pharisees' mouths in the plural of office: "By the prince of devils he casteth out devils."
Gospel Text β What Matthew Directly States
Matthew states this, and no more β the passage is three verses:
- The bringing: "when they were gone out, behold they brought him a dumb man, possessed with a devil" (9:32). The carriers are unnamed; "they" is the whole identification the text gives.
- The cure, stated as sequence: "after the devil was cast out, the dumb man spoke" (9:33). No command of Jesus is quoted; no touch, no word of his is recorded in this scene at all.
- The crowd's verdict: "the multitudes wondered, saying, Never was the like seen in Israel" (9:33).
- The Pharisees' counter-verdict: "But the Pharisees said, By the prince of devils he casteth out devils" (9:34).
Matthew does not state in this passage: the man's name, age, town, or how long he had been dumb or possessed; who brought him, or whether he came willingly; any word, gesture, or act of Jesus β the exorcism itself happens inside the clause "after the devil was cast out," without narration; whether the man spoke anything in particular, thanked anyone, or was seen again; or any answer by Jesus to the Pharisees' charge β in this passage the charge stands unanswered, its reply belonging to the fuller controversy the sheet treats at Event 058. Nor does Matthew connect the scene to the blind-and-dumb demoniac of his own chapter 12 (treated at Event 057): the overlap and difference of the two scenes are discussed under Scholarly Research and left unmerged.
Historical Context
Speechlessness and possession. In the Gospels' world, an affliction that sealed the mouth could be read as a spirit's work, and this text reads it so itself: the dumbness lifts when the devil is cast out β cause and cure are one event in the passage's own framing. The page reports that framing as the text's; the period also knew dumbness from birth, from injury, and from disease, and Matthew neither canvasses nor excludes them β he gives one man, one cause as his story states it, one cure.
The crowd's superlative. "Never was the like seen in Israel" is the strongest verdict the multitudes pronounce anywhere in this cycle of Matthew (compare their "we never saw the like" at the paralytic, Event 042). It is a verdict about the works collectively as much as about this cure: chapter 9 has stacked raising, healing, sight, and now speech. Matthew places the superlative and its contradiction in adjacent verses β wonder in v. 33, the Beelzebub charge in v. 34 β and the collision, not either sentence alone, is the scene's full statement.
The charge's first occurrence β in Matthew's arrangement. "By the prince of devils he casteth out devils" is the Beelzebub accusation in its shortest form, and in Matthew's book it occurs here first: the developed controversy β the charge argued, the kingdom-divided reply, the blasphemy against the Holy Ghost β belongs to his chapter 12, which the list treats at Events 057β058, earlier in its own order than this event. The list's harmony thus reaches the charge's brief first printing after its full form; the page declares the arrangement rather than letting the reader assume the list's order is the evangelist's. Within Matthew, the two printings stand as he left them: the slogan here, the trial of the slogan there.
Archaeological Evidence
Stated plainly: no artifact records this event. A brought man, an unrecorded act, two sentences of response: the scene has no site, building, or object, and nothing has been excavated or claimed for it.
- The ground's only contribution is the setting's ordinariness already documented for this cycle β the lakeside towns' houses and lanes through which a possessed man could be carried to a teacher (see Events 078β079). The page assigns it that weight and no more.
Ancient Sources
- Isaiah 35:6 (DRC) β "Then shall the lame man leap as a hart, and the tongue of the dumb shall be free." The prophet's sign-list (its blind-opening clause stood at Event 079) contains this scene's act in advance: the dumb tongue loosed. Matthew quotes nothing here; the verse is cited as the background the act carries in Israel's Scriptures.
- The fuller controversy, Matthew 12:24β32 β the charge of v. 34 argued out at length, treated in this list at Event 058 (with the dumb demoniac who occasions it at Event 057). Cited here as the canon's own cross-reference: the reader who wants the charge answered is sent where the list answers it; this page does not import the answer into a passage whose point is partly that none is given.
- No parallel to this scene exists in Mark, Luke, or John.
Scholarly Research
- One scene or two. Matthew 9:32β34 (a dumb demoniac) and Matthew 12:22β24 (a blind and dumb demoniac) present the standing doublet problem in its sharpest form, since both are Matthew's own and both draw the same Pharisaic charge. The discussions: (1) two distinct occasions β dumbness alone here, blindness added there, different crowds, the charge a refrain the Pharisees repeated; (2) one tradition doubled by the evangelist or his sources, told once in the chapter-9 collection and again at the controversy it properly introduces. The sheet prints them as two events (080 here; 057 for the chapter-12 scene, with its charge at 058) and the list follows the sheet; the debate is stated and not adjudicated, as with the blind men of Event 079.
- The unanswered charge. Commentators note the rhetorical exposure of v. 34's position: it ends a chapter of wonders with the opposition's explanation standing naked and unanswered β either Matthew's deliberate suspension (the answer reserved for chapter 12, where it becomes a set-piece) or the trace of an originally independent charge-tradition. Both readings work from the same datum: in this passage, no reply is given. The page preserves the exposure rather than relieving it.
- The exorcism without an exorcist's act. Among the Gospel exorcisms this is the barest: no command quoted, no struggle, no spirit's cry or name (contrast Event 076). Form critics file it as a summary-miracle β the wonder stated in its effect β and its very bareness is regularly cited for the tradition's confidence: the scene exists for its two verdicts, and everything else has been pared away. The observation is about the telling, and the page records it as such.
AVAKOD Interpretation
AVAKOD places this as Event 080, the last of the Matthew 9 cycle in the sheet's order and the closing event of the summer block (the ChronKey changes at Event 081).
Three things AVAKOD draws from the passage:
- Wonder and accusation, back to back. The chapter's whole argument is compressed into the passage's last two verses: the multitudes' "Never was the like seen in Israel" and the Pharisees' "By the prince of devils" are answers to the same evidence, and Matthew makes them neighbours. AVAKOD reads the juxtaposition as the evangelist's own framing of the cycle's end β the works now compel a verdict, and the verdicts divide β and labels the reading as its own.
- The charge stands unanswered here on purpose β the list's, and Matthew's. The chronicle resists the harmonist's instinct to footnote v. 34 with chapter 12's reply. In the list's order the reply has already been read (Event 058); in Matthew's book it is still coming. Both facts are declared on the page, and the silence in this passage is left exactly as loud as the text made it.
- The cycle closes on speech restored. The summer block that began with parables β speech in veiled forms (Events 061β062) β ends with a man who could not speak, speaking. AVAKOD notes the bracket without pressing it into a key: the block's first word was a sower's; its last scene gives a dumb man his voice and two crowds their verdicts. The pattern is the arrangement's, and the page says no more than that.
Chronology note: Summer 32 AD (AD 33 framework); the vault stub and the sheet's original-date column read "Summer 29 AD." This is the last event under the ChronKey 003206010000; Event 081 turns the season (Fall 32 AD) and the key with it. Matthew's summary verses that follow in his book (9:35β38 β the tour resumed and the harvest saying) are not part of this event's assignment in the sheet and are not quoted here.
Sources & Verification
Checked for this page, 2026-10-20:
- Bible text β Douay-Rheims (Challoner), Matthew 9:32β34, quoted verse by verse from the DRC.db database held in the AVAKOD vault (Douay-Rheims Bible, Challoner Revision, Public Domain), Matthew = book 47, duplicates deduplicated by verse. Every quoted verse line was machine-checked against DRC.db, this three-verse block included in the check. Inline Old Testament quotation verified against the same database: Isaiah 35:6 (book 27).
- Master list data β title (Jesus heals a demon-possessed man), date (Summer 32 AD), place (Galilee), and reference (Matthew 9:32β34) checked against the JERUSALEN master sheet, event 80 (row 84). The sheet's original-date column reads "Summer 29 AD," which is also the vault stub's date; the AD 33 framework date governs on this page. The vault stub's title agrees with the sheet's.
- Order note β the charge of v. 34 occurs in Matthew's book before the chapter-12 controversy treated at Events 057β058; the list's order reaches it afterward, and the page declares this rather than presenting the list's sequence as the evangelist's.
Status: draft for the AVAKOD website, Event 080. Not yet published.
Master Database — AVAKOD_229_EVENTS_WORKING (11).csv