Event 172 β The Sadducees question Jesus about resurrection
Era: IX β Passion Week: Tuesday Teaching (era name as given in the vault stub)
Gospel Reference: Matthew 22:23β33; Mark 12:18β27; Luke 20:27β40
Location: Jerusalem (sheet and stub) β in the Temple, in the course of the Tuesday teaching (Events 166β176).
AVAKOD date: March 31, 33 AD (master list, AD 33 framework; ChronKey 003303310000). The stub reads "April 7 30 AD" and the sheet's original-date column "April 7, 30 AD" β the AD 30 framework date, superseded.
Note on the frame. The sheet's title stands as written. Third in the run of Tuesday questions (Events 171β174), this is the Sadducees' attempt after the Pharisees' tax trap failed (Event 171); Matthew marks the day-link himself β "That day there came to him the Sadducees" (22:23). All three evangelists define the party by the doctrine at stake before the question is put: they "say there is no resurrection" (Matthew, Mark), "deny that there is any resurrection" (Luke). The question is engineered as a reductio out of Moses' own levirate law, and the answer comes in two movements β the nature of the risen life, then a proof drawn from the bush, from the one corpus whose authority both sides in the dispute fully shared. The three forms are printed entire and unmerged; Luke's additions and his closing applause are his own.
My Study β Event 172
Sign in to mark this event as read and keep your own notes. Sign in
Bible Text β Douay-Rheims, Challoner Revision
Matthew 22:23β33
23 That day there came to him the Sadducees, who say there is no resurrection; and asked him,
24 Saying: Master, Moses said: If a man die having no son, his brother shall marry his wife and raise up issue to his brother.
25 Now there were with us seven brethren: and the first having married a wife, died; and not having issue, left his wife to his brother.
26 In like manner the second and the third and so on, to the seventh.
27 And last of all the woman died also.
28 At the resurrection therefore, whose wife of the seven shall she be? For they all had her.
29 And Jesus answering, said to them: You err, not knowing the Scriptures nor the power of God.
30 For in the resurrection they shall neither marry nor be married, but shall be as the angels of God in heaven.
31 And concerning the resurrection of the dead, have you not read that which was spoken by God, saying to you:
32 I am the God of Abraham and the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob? He is not the God of the dead but of the living.
33 And the multitudes hearing it were in admiration at his doctrine.
Mark 12:18β27
18 And there came to him the Sadducees, who say there is no resurrection. And they asked him, saying:
19 Master, Moses wrote unto us that if any man's brother die and leave his wife behind him and leave no children, his brother should take his wife and raise up seed to his brother.
20 Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife and died leaving no issue.
21 And the second took her and died: and neither did he leave any issue. And the third in like manner.
22 And the seven all took her in like manner and did not leave issue. Last of all the woman also died.
23 In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise again, whose wife shall she be of them? For the seven had her to wife.
24 And Jesus answering, saith to them: Do ye not therefore err, because you know not the scriptures nor the power of God?
25 For when they shall rise again from the dead, they shall neither marry, nor be married, but are as the angels in heaven.
26 And as concerning the dead that they rise again have you not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spoke to him, saying: I am the God of Abraham and the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob?
27 He is not the God of the dead, but of the living. You therefore do greatly err.
Luke 20:27β40
27 And there came to him some of the Sadducees, who deny that there is any resurrection: and they asked him,
28 Saying: Master, Moses wrote unto us: If any man's brother die, having a wife, and he leave no children, that his brother should take her to wife and raise up seed unto his brother.
29 There were therefore seven brethren: and the first took a wife and died without children.
30 And the next took her to wife: and he also died childless.
31 And the third took her. And in like manner, all the seven: and they left no children and died.
32 Last of all the woman died also.
33 In the resurrection therefore, whose wife of them shall she be? For all the seven had her to wife.
34 And Jesus said to them: The children of this world marry and are given in marriage:
35 But they that shall be accounted worthy of that world and of the resurrection from the dead shall neither be married nor take wives.
36 Neither can they die any more for they are equal to the angels and are the children of God, being the children of the resurrection.
37 Now that the dead rise again, Moses also shewed at the bush, when he called the Lord: The God of Abraham and the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob.
38 For he is not the God of the dead, but of the living: for all live to him.
39 And some of the scribes answering, said to him: Master, thou hast said well.
40 And after that they durst not ask him any more questions.
Note on the proof-text: the argument of the second movement is tense. God names himself to Moses at the bush β Exodus 3:6, "I am the God of thy father, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob" β centuries after the patriarchs died, and in the present tense. Mark makes the location explicit: "in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spoke to him." The conclusion all three forms draw is identical: "He is not the God of the dead, but of the living."
Gospel Text β What the Gospels Directly State
The three forms agree on the case, the two-movement answer, and the proof; each keeps its own colour:
- The questioners and their ground. Sadducees, defined by the denial (above). Their case is built on Moses' levirate rule, quoted from Deuteronomy 25:5 in the Ancient Sources below: a man dying childless, his brother marries the widow "to raise up seed to his brother."
- The case. Seven brethren in sequence marry the same woman; each dies childless; "last of all the woman died also." The question: "In the resurrection therefore, whose wife of them shall she be? For all the seven had her to wife."
- First movement β the error named, then the risen life. Matthew: "You err, not knowing the Scriptures nor the power of God." Mark: "Do ye not therefore err, because you know not the scriptures nor the power of God?" The risen neither marry nor are given in marriage, "but shall be as the angels of God in heaven." Luke expands: "The children of this world marry and are given in marriage: but they that shall be accounted worthy of that world and of the resurrection from the dead shall neither be married nor take wives. Neither can they die any more for they are equal to the angels and are the children of God, being the children of the resurrection."
- Second movement β the proof from the bush. "And concerning the resurrection of the dead, have you not read that which was spoken by God" β "I am the God of Abraham and the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob? He is not the God of the dead but of the living." Luke's conclusion adds his gloss: "for all live to him."
- The outcomes differ in shade. Matthew: "the multitudes hearing it were in admiration at his doctrine" β and his next verse opens Event 173 on the news "that he had silenced the Sadducees." Luke: "some of the scribes answering, said to him: Master, thou hast said well. And after that they durst not ask him any more questions." Mark records no reply from the Sadducees; his form ends on the verdict itself: "You therefore do greatly err."
The Gospels do not state in this passage: any reply by the Sadducees themselves; where the woman would belong β the question is dissolved by the first movement, not answered on its own terms; why the case numbers seven brothers (a construction of the questioners; see the Tobit proposal in Scholarly Research); or anything of the intermediate state of the dead. Luke's "after that they durst not ask him any more questions" (20:40) stands in his arrangement before Matthew's next question-event (Event 173); the two arrangements are printed as they stand, not reconciled β in Luke's own sequence the scribes' applause closes the question-series he records, while Matthew continues it with the Pharisees' gathering.
Historical Context
The Sadducees. The priestly-aristocratic party of the Temple establishment. Luke's own later summary, Acts 23:8, states the platform the evangelists presuppose: "For the Sadducees say that there is no resurrection, neither angel, nor spirit: but the Pharisees confess both." Josephus gives the same profile from outside the New Testament (below). Resurrection was therefore not a neutral topic but the party line itself β which is why the question is put as mockery-by-arithmetic, and why an answer from the Torah matters: the Sadducees' case rests on Moses, and Jesus answers from Moses.
The levirate. Deuteronomy 25:5β10 obliges a brother to marry his brother's childless widow; the firstborn "shall call by his name, that his name be not abolished out of Israel." The institution's narrative ancestor is Genesis 38 (Judah, Er, and Onan). The Sadducees' sevenfold iteration is the law stretched to absurdity on purpose: if the resurrection restores this world's arrangements, the law itself manufactures an unassignable wife.
Resurrection in the later Scriptures. The doctrine the Sadducees denied stands in the Prophets and Writings β Daniel 12:2: "many of those that sleep in the dust of the earth, shall awake: some unto life everlasting, and others unto reproach, to see it always." Jesus does not argue from Daniel here. The page notes the choice because the commentators note it: with Sadducees, the proof is taken from the bush, the ground both parties hold.
Archaeological Evidence
Honest limit first: no artifact records this exchange.
- The Temple courts. The setting is the same public teaching space as Events 162β171; nothing finer is claimed.
- Ossuary burial. The period's Jerusalem practice of secondary burial β bones gathered into limestone ossuaries in family tombs β is excavated in quantity around the city and witnesses the era's intense concern with the dead and their names, the world in which a question about whose wife a woman is at the resurrection was a live party dispute. It is background to the question's currency, not evidence for the exchange, and is filed at that strength.
Ancient Sources
- Deuteronomy 25:5 β the levirate rule the case is built on: "the wife of the deceased shall not marry to another: but his brother shall take her, and raise up seed for his brother"; v. 6 adds the name-purpose: the first son "he shall call by his name, that his name be not abolished out of Israel."
- Exodus 3:6 β "I am the God of thy father, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob"; and 3:15, where the same name is God's "memorial unto all generations." The second movement's text.
- Acts 23:8 β "For the Sadducees say that there is no resurrection, neither angel, nor spirit: but the Pharisees confess both" β Luke's platform summary, the passage Paul's defence will exploit (Acts 23:6).
- Daniel 12:2 β the resurrection text not argued from here (quoted in Historical Context above).
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.1.4 (Β§Β§16β17) and Jewish War 2.8.14 (Β§Β§164β166) β the Sadducees, in Josephus's account, deny the soul's survival and its rewards and punishments after death, and hold to the written laws against the Pharisees' traditions. The party profile from the period's own historian, at that strength.
- No source outside the three Gospels records the exchange itself.
Scholarly Research
- The argument's logic. The proof from the bush turns on the present tense of the covenant name: God is β not was β the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and God is not God of the dead. Scholars note the argument works within the period's scriptural reasoning (the covenant formula as a living relation), and debate its exact force: whether it demonstrates resurrection of the body as such, or the patriarchs' continued life from which resurrection follows. The distinction (immortality of the soul vs. resurrection) is a standing one in the commentaries; the passage's own conclusion is resurrection, since the question asked was about resurrection. Both the argument and the debate are printed; AVAKOD adjudicates neither.
- The Tobit proposal. A number of commentators have proposed that the Sadducees' case is modelled on Tobit's Sarah, who was given to seven husbands, each killed on the wedding night (Tobit 3:7β8; 6β7): the mockers' hypothetical would then be a tale their opponents cherished, turned against its own doctrine. The proposal is suggestive and unprovable; the Gospels do not cite Tobit, and the levirate law supplies the case without it. Filed as a proposal.
- Luke's hand. Luke's form is the most theological: "accounted worthy of that world," "children of the resurrection," "for all live to him." The three forms are kept unmerged so the reader can see where the common answer ends and each evangelist's elaboration begins.
AVAKOD Interpretation
- The answer changes the category, not the arithmetic. "Whose wife shall she be?" presupposes that the resurrection extends this world's arrangements of possession. The first movement denies the presupposition: marriage belongs to the world where men die ("the children of this world marry"); the risen "cannot die any more." AVAKOD's reading, stated as reading: the trap is answered by refusing its frame before refuting its doctrine.
- The proof is taken from the questioners' own ground. As the tax question was answered with the questioners' own coin (Event 171), this question is answered from the book both parties own β the bush, not Daniel. AVAKOD notes the method because the week's debates turn on it twice: the answer's authority is chosen to meet the asker where he stands.
- The silencing is cumulative. Matthew's bridge into Event 173 β the Pharisees gather because "he had silenced the Sadducees" β is the list's narrative fact, and Luke's scribes applaud before his questions close. The Tuesday examination is failing party by party; AVAKOD keeps the sequence visible because the evangelists built it so.
Sources & Verification
Checked for this page, 2026-10-20:
- Bible text β Douay-Rheims (Challoner), Matthew 22:23β33; Mark 12:18β27; Luke 20:27β40, quoted from the user's DRC.db (Matthew = book 47, Mark = 48, Luke = 49), deduped by verse with MIN(text) and machine-checked against the database before upload: 35 verse lines, 0 mismatches. The database was verified before use (37,474,304 bytes; 260,785 verse rows). Inline quotations of Deuteronomy 25:5β6, Exodus 3:6, Acts 23:8, and Daniel 12:2 were likewise machine-checked against the database (4 quotations, 0 problems). Versification probed before extraction: the database's Matthew 22 (46 vv.), Mark 12 (44), and Luke 20 (47) all match the modern chapters β no database quirk of earlier batches touches this range.
- Master list data β title, date (March 31, 33 AD), place (Jerusalem), and references from the JERUSALEN master sheet, row 176, verified by column C (event 172 = row 176).
- Stub matching declared β this page replaces the content of stub file "175 - The Sadducees question Jesus about resurrection.md" (Drive id 1XGbvfp9lgTdSe3osVbzP8Z_0rKt9SSWO), matched to sheet Event 172 by identical Gospel references (Matthew 22:23-33; Mark 12:18-27; Luke 20:27-40), identical title, place, and the stub's date "April 7 30 AD" equalling the sheet's original-date column for Event 172 (April 7, 30 AD). The stub's number belongs to the stub set's offset in this stretch (sheet events 166β182 in stubs 169β185); filename kept as found. Era "IX β Passion Week: Tuesday Teaching" is stub 175's, retained.
- Party profile and levirate β Acts 23:8 and Josephus (Antiquities 18.1.4; War 2.8.14) cited for the Sadducees' doctrine at the strength stated; Deuteronomy 25:5β6 and Genesis 38 cited for the levirate institution.
Status: draft for the AVAKOD website, Event 172. Not yet published.
Master Database — AVAKOD_229_EVENTS_WORKING (11).csv